Sunday, April 3, 2016

Cardinal Schonborn must be told that there are no known cases of someone saved outside the Church

  • What Does the Choice of Exhortation 

  • Presenters Tell Us?


  • He (Cardinal Schonborn) drew an analogy with Lumen 

    In the same way, he suggested, there may be virtues and 
  • Gentium,truth in relationships that fall short of the Church’s
  •  full vision of marriage as a permanent, lifelong union between
  •  a man  a document of the Second Vatican Council (1962-65),
  •  which taught that there are “elements of sanctification 
  • and of truth” outside the visible boundaries of the Catholic
  •  Church.

  • Lionel: 
  • He is referring to Lumen Gentium 8 which says
  •  there are 'elements of sanctification and truth' 
  • in other religions. Cardinal Schonborn like Cardinal 
  • Ratzinger infers that LG 8 refers not to invisible for 
  • us cases, but personally known people ,saved without
  •  the baptism of water in the Catholic Church. So LG 
  • 8 for them contradicts and rejects the dogma extra 
  • ecclesiam nulla salus. From here we get Pope Benedict's
  •  'development of doctrine' on EENS.
    Cardinal Schonborn is implying that if the Church's 
  • teaching on extra ecclesiam nulla salus can be changed 
  • with LG 8 then why not change other teachings of the 
  • Church.
    Their entire new theology is based on mixing up what 
  • is invisible as being visible and they get away with it.
    It is important for us to affirm LG 8, LG 16, UR 3, NA 
  • 2 etc as being invisible cases. They are hypothetical 
  • cases. So they cannot be an exception in 2016 to the 
  • 16th century missionaries interpretation of the dogma 
  • extra ecclesiam nulla salus.We cannot know of any 
  • hypothetical case which is objectively visible.
    We must affirm that there is nothing in Vatican Council
  •  II ( including hypothetical LG 14) which contradicts
  •  extra ecclesiam nulla salus.
  • -Lionel Andrades
http://www.onepeterfive.com/what-does-the-choice-of-exhortation-presenters-tell-us/

No comments: