The Society of St.Pius X (SSPX) has to respond to the Notification of Bishop Marcello Semeraro,Bishop of Albano, by citing doctrine which supports them. They have ignored this in the Press Release which they have issued.
They have some good points in their Press Release but they have not referred to Vatican Council II being in agreement with Tradition and especially the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus.Is the Bishop of Albano willing to accept extra ecclesiam nulla salus ? They have not asked.
The issue is Vatican Council II. The bishop is using an irrational premise in the interpretation.With this irrational interpretation of UR 3,NA 2 etc he justifies his understanding of ecumenism etc .This is doctrine for him.
He wants the SSPX to accept this irrational version of the Council which will be a break with the traditonal teaching on other religiions etc.Based on this irrational understanding of the Council he is trying to discipline the SSPX.
-Lionel Andrades
____________________________________________
Then they should ask the bishop if he is willing to accept this interpretation of the Council II.This is a doctrinal issue.
Vatican Council II can be interpreted without the irrational premise.It is then Vatican Council II is non heretical and has a hermeneutic of continuity. They must ask the Bishop of Albano to first accept this rational version of Vatican Council II and then they could follow.They could have announced that Vatican Council II can be interpreted with or without an irrational premise. Without the irrational premise the Council supports the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus and Tradition. Then they should ask the bishop if he is willing to accept this interpretation of the Council II.This is a doctrinal issue.
The SSPX must respond to Bishop Semeraro by citing Catholic doctrine on Vatican Council II which supports their positionhttp://eucharistandmission.blo...
I
f the Bishops of Argentine and Albano cannot accept Vatican Council II without the irrational inference, then it is a doctrinal issue
http://eucharistandmission.blo...
http://eucharistandmission.blo...
Ecclesia Dei, SSPX and the Latin Mass Society interpret Vatican Council II with the same irrationality as the two bishopshttp://eucharistandmission.blo...
The Bishop of Albano will not like this. But then at least he cannot say that the SSPX has to accept Vatican Council II (with the premise) http://eucharistandmission.blo...
SSPX APPEAL TO BISHOP MARCELLO SEMERARO TO ENDORSE VATICAN COUNCIL II WITHOUT THE FALSE PREMISE FOR AN AGREEMENThttp://eucharistandmission.blo...
We call upon Bishop Semeraro to please do the same. Affirm Vatican Council II as we interpret it http://eucharistandmission.blo...
Posts
No comments:
Post a Comment