Friday, October 31, 2014

How can they return to the traditional doctrine of the Church when the SSPX is making the same doctrinal error as Rome ?

A Catholic Thinker:
The return of Rome and the bishops to the traditional doctrine of the Church.
  • Lionel:
    How can they return to the traditional doctrine of the Church when the SSPX is making the same doctrinal error as Rome ?

A Catholic Thinker .
I’m short on time, but feel the need to point out for the benefit of the forum that the doctrinal errors lie with Lionel. And, Lionel, no offense, but you’re really proving to be a one-trick pony here.
    Lionel.
    If the doctrinal error lies with Lionel then show him precisely what is the error.
    I have mentioned precisely what is the doctrinal error being made by the traditionalists.
     
    The traditionalists and Cardinal Kaspar say:
    1.Lumen Gentium 16 is an exception to the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus.2.They both imply that those who are saved in invincible ignorance (LG 16) and without the baptism of water, are visible to us on earth.They would have to be known and visible to be exceptions to the dogma.

  • This is irrational. It is a new doctrine and a non traditional interpretation.
    The LG 16 text does not state that being saved in invincible ignorance is explicit and so is an exception to the salvation dogma. It has to be implied. And so it is implied wrongly by traditionalists and liberals.
    The Council of Trent and Mystici Corporis does not mention that implicit desire and being saved in invincible ignorance are explicit and so are exceptions to Tardition. This has to be inferred. It is inferred wrongly by SSPX priests and bishops.
    Vatican Council II no where says that there are explicit exceptions to the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus but since it is assumed that the dead are visible in the present times, it is wrongly inferred by the communities of Fr.Leonard Feeney in the USA , that the Council contradicts Tradition.
    Similar doctrinal errors can be pointed out with the Catechism of the Catholic Church 1257-1260 and the Letter of the Holy Office 1949.

-Lionel Andrades

No comments: