A CALL TO UNITY MUST BE BASED ON DOCTRINE

 

A call to Catholics for unity must be based on Catholic doctrine.

Rorate Caeili is not in unity with the Catholic Church.There cannot be a call to unity based on heresy.

 

 

1. For Rorate Caeili Vatican Council II contradicts the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus,the Syllabus of Errors and Tradition on the issue of other religions and Christian communities and churches, since Rorate correspondents consider all salvation, referred to in Vatican Council II as being visible to them, explicit on earth and Heaven. It is true the Council then would contradict the dogma.The Council would contradict the dogma when this irrational premise is used! Any Church document would contradict Tradition when this irrational premise is used.

So it is not Catholic doctrine to say that we can see the dead in Heaven and also on earth who are known, visible exceptions to Tradition. They would have to be visible to Rorate Caeili correspondents for them to be exceptions to traditional teaching and Rorate implies they are visible.

 

2.If Rorate Caeili would say Vatican Council II does not contradict the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus, the Syllabus of Errors and Tradition on the issue of other religions and Christian communities and churches, it means Rorate correspondnents consider all salvation, referred to in Vatican Council II as being invisible to them on earth.They are hypothetical cases, possibilities, known only to God. Vatican Council II would not contradict the dogma.The Council would not contradict the dogma when the irrational premise is not used!

Ad Gentes 7 affirms the traditional teaching on other religions and Christian communities and churches.

So Vatican Council II affirms the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus. The Council is pro-Fr.Leonard Feeney.

There is no salvation outside the Church, known to Rorate correspondents in 2014. Neither does Vatican Council II say that the dead  on earth now saved in Heaven are visible to us.

Rorate Caeili is not willing like many Traditionalists to affirm this teaching or even to discuss it.-Lionel Andrades

January 20, 2014
More nonsense on Rorate Caeili

http://eucharistandmission.blogspot.it/2014/01/more-nonsense-on-rorate-caeili.html