SSPX IF THE SISTERS HAVE CANONICAL STATUS SO CAN YOU

Reject the Muller-Ladaria version of Vatican Council II and accept the Council in accord with the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus.

SSPX priests call up the Slaves of the Immaculate Heart of Mary in Worcester USA.

May be the conversation will go like this:-

SSPX PRIEST : Our communiqué (July 19, 2012) affirmed the dogma outside the church no salvation and excluded any exceptions.

SISTERS OF ST.BENEDICT CENTER: Yes there are no exceptions to the dogma also for us.

SSPX: We don’t know anyone saved in invincible ignorance and the baptism of desire.

SISTERS: Neither do we.

SSPX: Since we don’t know any exceptions, the literal interpretation of the dogma strands.

SISTERS:We don’t know any exceptions and the literal interpretation of the dogma according to Fr.Leonard Feeney still is the teaching of the Church.

SSPX: So if there are no exceptions to the dogma on exclusive salvation then there are no exceptions to the Syllabus of Errors.

SISTERS: None.

SSPX:Neither are there exceptions to Mystici Corporis and other Church-documents.

SISTERS: None. Since invincible ignorance and implicit desire are acknowledged – but they are not exceptions to the dogma on salvation.

SSPX: So Vatican Council II also does not contradict the dogma.

SISTERS:It does not, since we do not know any exceptions.We do not know any one saved with a good conscience or in invincible ignorance (LG 16) or the seeds of the Word etc. While Ad Gentes 7 supports the dogma.

SSPX: So if Vatican Council II does not contradict extra ecclesiam nulla salus, the Syllabus of Errors and other magisterial documents then the Council is traditional.

SISTERS: Yes. It is traditional.

SSPX: So your really saying the Council says there is no salvation outside the Church?

SISTERS:Yes. It is saying there is no salvation outside the church in the present times.None that we know of or can know of.

SSPX: If there is no salvation outside the church then there cannot be a theology of religions or an ecclesiology of communion.

SISTERS: No.It would be irrational.

SSPX: So the SSPX can accept Vatican Council Ii and maintain its traditional position on other religions, ecumenism and religious liberty.

SISTERS: Yes, since the Council affirms the literal interpretation of the dogma outside the church no salvation.

SSPX: So we can publicly affirm the Council and maintain our traditional values on faith and morals.

SISTERS: Yes the Council is traditional since you affirm the dogma like Fr.Leonard Feeney.
-Lionel Andrades